Chipotle Mayo Sardines on Rye

Chipotle mayo sardines on rye: tinned sardine fillets mashed with mayo, smoky chilli sauce, chives and lime, piled onto toasted rye bread with warm baby tomatoes. Lunch in under 10 minutes.

Open faced sardine mayo sandwich on rye bread on a blue plate with a black fork

My German, rye-loving girlfriend came up with this between teaching classes, when she wanted something quick, easy and delicious. It has been a staple in our house ever since.

My contributions were the chives and the tomatoes, which I give two minutes in the air fryer. An air fryer is great for jobs like this, when you want to cook one small thing without getting several pans out.

It is an open sandwich with bags of flavour, on the table in under ten minutes.

Shopping and prep

  • Buy fillets in oil: Sardine fillets rather than whole fish, and in olive oil rather than tomato sauce. They may be labelled pilchard fillets, which is essentially the same thing.
  • Chilli sauce: I like chipotle for its smokiness, but any chilli sauce you love will work.
  • Tomatoes: They do not have to be cooked. Raw, they can go straight into the bowl with the sardines. Cooked, they are better on top.
  • Bread: Several brands of rye bread are labelled wheat free or gluten free. Use whichever gluten-free bread you like if you have a favourite.

Serves 2 | Prep 5 mins | Cook 5 mins | Total 10 mins

Ingredients

  • 2 slices rye bread
  • 30g (1oz) baby tomatoes, about 4, halved
  • ½ tsp olive oil (optional)
  • 140g (5oz) sardine fillets in olive oil, drained weight (about 2 tins)
  • 1 tsp mayonnaise
  • 1 tsp chilli sauce, ideally chipotle
  • 2 tsp finely chopped chives
  • ½ tsp lime juice
  • ¼ tsp fine sea salt, plus a pinch for the tomatoes
  • Pinch of ground black pepper

Method

Step 1: Toast the rye

  1. Toast the rye bread on both sides, in a toaster or a dry pan. The colour will not change much, but the surface and edges should crisp up slightly.

Step 2: Cook the tomatoes

  1. Toss the tomatoes with the olive oil, if using, and a pinch of salt.
  2. Cook in an air fryer at 200°C (400°F) for 2 minutes, or in a hot frying pan for a couple of minutes, until just softened.

Step 3: Mix the sardines

  1. Drain the oil from the sardines and tip the fillets into a bowl. Break them up with a fork.
  2. Add the mayonnaise, chilli sauce, most of the chives, the lime juice, salt and pepper.
  3. Mix again with the fork.

Step 4: Serve

  1. Pile the sardines onto the toasted rye.
  2. Top with the tomatoes and the remaining chives, and serve.

Notes

  • Raw tomato version: Skip the cooking and stir the halved tomatoes into the sardine mixture instead.
  • Storage: Best eaten straight away. The sardine mix will keep for a day in the fridge, but toast the bread fresh.

This recipe is yours, free and no strings. If it made you look like you have your life together, you can tip the kitchen to keep recipes like it coming. Want the full collection? There's a membership from $5/month, but a one-off is very welcome too.

Tip the kitchen (choose your amount)

Why it has stuck around

A tin of sardines is one of the most useful things you can keep in the cupboard, and this is my favourite thing to do with one. Smoky, sharp and rich, on bread with real chew, and full of omega 3s. All of that for ten minutes of your lunch break.

Russell